The History of the Christian Church
by Henry C. Sheldon
Originally Published by Thomas Y. Crowell and Co., 1895
First Period, From Pentecost to Constantine
THE EARLY CHURCH
V.--Controversies on Anthropology
With some revisions and type-setting by
http://edwardtbabinski.us (2005)

V.--CONTROVERSIES ON ANTHROPOLOGY.

The Eastern Church, in this period, indulged very little debate on the subject of man's sinfulness and the province of divine grace in his recovery. While Eastern bishops in the synod at Ephesus in 431 pronounced against Pelagianism, their decision was more or less influenced by extraneous motives, and was not based upon any thorough investigation of the Pelagian system, or upon any profound aversion to the same. It was in the Latin Church alone that the great problems of anthropology received a profound and earnest canvassing.

The radical theories of Pelagius, a monk from Britain, were the primary cause of the controversy that arose. The more essential features of his doctrinal system were a denial of inherited corruption in the moral nature of man, a strong assertion of the freedom of the will, and a decided emphasis upon man's ability to work out his own salvation as opposed to his radical dependence upon divine grace. Such a system naturally provoked the profound opposition of Augustine, whose ardent soul was ever burning with zeal for the honor of divine grace. All the powers of his great mind were brought to the task of refutation. The Pauline conception of sin and grace found in him a more appreciative interpreter than the Church had as yet produced. He criticised, to good effect, the superficial points of Pelagianism, but greatly impaired his service by inculcating an exaggerated idea of divine sovereignty. Augustine was the first of the Christian Fathers to advocate the creed of unconditional predestination.

The positive beginning of the Pelagian controversy may be located about the year 412, when Cœlestius, a prominent disciple of Pelagius, was excommunicated by a Carthaginian synod. In 416 two African synods condemned the Pelagian doctrines, and the Roman bishop Innocent expressed his agreement with their decision. His successor, Zosimus, after a temporary show of favor to the condemned party, gave the full weight of his authority to their proscription. Some adherents still defended the doctrines of Pelagius, among whom the learned and talented Julian of Eclanum especially distinguished himself. No new sect, however, was formed in the interest of Pelagaianism; and, as a theoretical system, it was pretty well overthrown in the Latin Church before the death of Augustine. Semi-Pelagianism, which thrived especially in Gaul, maintained itself for a longer space, and was not emphatically disowned in that region till the sixth century. Still, it was not strict Augustinianism which held the field. In point of theory, the Latin Church showed an inclination to modify the radical tenets of Augustine; while in its spirit and practice it increasingly paid tribute to the idea of salvation by works, and really nurtured a crude species of practical Pelagianism.

All variations on the original Sheldon History volumes, including text revisions, greek art files associated with the text, and revised format ©2005 http://edwardtbabinski.us

Sheldon's History of the Christian Church (Five Volumes) may be purchased from Christian Book Distributors

---

---

RELATED ARTICLES
Pelagianism
Fifth century heresy advanced by followers who held a rejection of the belief in the original sin affecting newborns, alone affecting Adam. Man's ability to possess spiritual good apart from divine grace.

Original Thoughts on The Original Sin
On the 'original sin' and the guilt associated with it, includes compiled quotes by Deitrich Bonhoeffer, Conrad Hyers and Edward Babinski.

Doctrines on the Original Sin
The Early Church Father's views on Hell, and Sin, and Baptism.

Free Will Is No Excuse
Free will is a concept that has at least three different meanings; the casually-independent view, the deterministic view, and the true-to-self view. Understanding their differences is crucial to any discussion of free will.

The Fallacy of Free Will
Essay on Free Will, and the author's doubts that people are guided by religious beliefs, but more by environmental conditioning.

Article last updated October 22, 2005
Certified error free by http://htmlvalidator.com